Moissanite vs. Diamond: A Simple, Honest Guide

Picking a gemstone for a special piece of jewelry—like an engagement ring, an anniversary gift, or even a little gift for yourself—can be confusing. You might think, “Should I pick a diamond, the classic choice, or moissanite, the shiny new option?” At Pear Jewels, we want to help make this choice simple and clear for you.

Diamonds: 

Diamonds have always been the star when it comes to love and commitment. There’s something amazing about wearing a stone that is billions of years old, made deep in the Earth. It’s more than just a gem; it’s a piece of history and nature’s artwork. That’s why so many people choose diamonds—they’re timeless, rare, and full of meaning.

Diamonds have a certain glow, a sparkle that’s familiar and comforting. It’s not just about how they shine but what they represent: a love that’s strong and steady, a promise that’s meant to last.

Moissanite: 

Moissanite has its own special story. It was first discovered in a meteor crater, meaning it came from the stars. Imagine wearing a gem that once traveled through space! That’s what makes moissanite unique—it’s not just a beautiful stone, but one with a magical and rare origin.

Today, moissanite is made in labs, making it an ethical and eco-friendly choice. If you care about the environment or want a gem that comes without guilt, moissanite is a great option. And that shine? It’s bright, bold, and full of energy, almost as if it’s showing off. If you want a gem that stands out and makes a statement, moissanite is perfect for you.

Comparing the Sparkle: 

Both diamonds and moissanite sparkle, but they do it differently.

• Diamonds: Their sparkle is gentle and classic, with a white brilliance that feels elegant and timeless.
• Moissanite: Its shine is more intense and bold due to its higher refractive index. It splits light into colorful rainbows, creating a “fire” that’s eye-catching and vibrant.

Color and Clarity

Diamonds come in different shades and have tiny imperfections called inclusions, which make each one unique. The best diamonds are clear and colorless, but even small tints and flaws add character and tell their own story.

Moissanite is almost always clear and colorless. If you like a perfect, clean look without small flaws, moissanite is an easy choice.

Durability: Long lasting strength

Jewelry is meant to be worn and enjoyed through all of life’s moments.

• Diamonds: They are the hardest natural substance on Earth, scoring a 10 on the Mohs scale. This means you can wear a diamond every day, knowing it will handle whatever life brings.
• Moissanite: It scores 9.25 on the Mohs scale, making it almost as hard as a diamond. It’s tough enough for everyday wear, so you don’t have to worry about it getting scratched or losing its sparkle.

What About the Cost?

Diamonds can be a big investment. Their price depends on factors like size, clarity, and more. For many, paying more for a diamond is about honoring tradition and choosing the classic option.

Moissanite gives you a beautiful sparkle at a much lower cost. Choosing moissanite means you can save money for other important things - like planning your dream wedding, saving for the future, or taking a special trip together.

Making an Ethical Choice

We understand that some people worry about where their gems come from. Diamonds can raise concerns about mining practices and their impact on the environment, though there are certified ethical diamonds to consider.

Moissanite, being lab-created, doesn’t involve mining at all. It’s an ideal choice if you care about sustainability and want peace of mind knowing your gem was made with the planet in mind.

So, Which One Feels Right to You?

Choosing between moissanite and diamonds isn’t about which is better—it’s about what feels right for you. Diamonds have a rich history and tradition that many people cherish. Moissanite is modern, full of sparkle, and has a story that’s as unique as yours.

At Pear Jewels, we believe your jewelry should reflect who you are. Visit us at pearjewels.com to explore our collections, or reach out if you need help. We’re here to help you find not just a gem, but a piece that celebrates your journey, your story, and your love.